# Let's Encrypt (ACME DNS-01) with Jarl

The DNS-01 challenge proves that you control a domain by publishing a TXT
record at `_acme-challenge.<domain>`. Jarl does this through its API, so no
dynamic updates (`allow-update`, nsupdate) are needed. That matters because
Jarl regenerates zone files and doesn't allow dynamic zones.

**When a `jarl acme` command returns, named is already serving the record.**
Jarl reloads the zone and checks the new serial with `rndc zonestatus`
before it reports success, so hooks need no "sleep and hope" delay. If you
also run secondary servers, they pick the change up through NOTIFY within
seconds. Add a short `--dns-propagation-seconds`/`--dnssleep` only if your
CA checks them too.

## 1. A token that can only publish challenges

```sh
jarl user create certbot --no-password --role acme --comment "Let's Encrypt"
jarl token create certbot --user certbot --role acme -q > certbot.token
sudo install -m 0600 certbot.token /etc/jarl/certbot.token && rm certbot.token
```

The `acme` role is `records:write names=_acme-challenge.* types=TXT`. The
token can add and remove challenge TXT records in any zone and nothing
else. To restrict it to your zones, use an explicit grant instead:

```sh
jarl user create certbot --no-password --grant "records:write zones=adbraun.lol names=_acme-challenge.* types=TXT"
```

## 2. What `jarl acme` does

```sh
jarl acme set   DOMAIN VALUE...     # publish
jarl acme unset DOMAIN [VALUE...]   # remove these values, or all of them
```

* `DOMAIN` is the name on the certificate. `_acme-challenge.` is added for
  you, and a leading `*.` is dropped, since a wildcard and its apex share one
  challenge name. A name that already starts with `_acme-challenge.` is used
  as it is.
* The zone is found automatically: the longest matching primary zone.
* If the zone exists in several **views** (split DNS), the record is written
  into every view, so the CA (on the internet, in your external view) and
  your internal resolvers see the same thing. `--view NAME` limits it to one.
* All values and views go into one changeset. Setting a value that is
  already there succeeds, so a retried hook doesn't fail, and removing a
  value that isn't there succeeds as well.
* The record TTL is 60 seconds (`--ttl`).

## 3. certbot

```sh
sudo certbot certonly --manual --preferred-challenges dns \
  --manual-auth-hook    'jarl --token @/etc/jarl/certbot.token acme certbot-auth' \
  --manual-cleanup-hook 'jarl --token @/etc/jarl/certbot.token acme certbot-cleanup' \
  -d adbraun.lol -d '*.adbraun.lol'
```

The hooks read `CERTBOT_DOMAIN` and `CERTBOT_VALIDATION` from certbot. Add
`--server https://ns1.adbraun.lol:8053` when certbot runs on another host,
or `--server http://127.0.0.1:8053` on the DNS server itself (root's jarl
CLI has no configuration file). certbot stores the hooks in the renewal
configuration, so `certbot renew` works unattended.

## 4. acme.sh

Install the DNS API hook that comes with Jarl:

```sh
cp contrib/acme.sh/dns_jarl.sh ~/.acme.sh/dnsapi/    # or from /usr/local/share/doc/jarl/contrib/
export JARL_SERVER=https://ns1.adbraun.lol:8053
export JARL_TOKEN=$(cat /etc/jarl/certbot.token)
acme.sh --issue --dns dns_jarl -d adbraun.lol -d '*.adbraun.lol'
```

The hook calls the `jarl` CLI, which must be installed on the same host. It
remembers `JARL_SERVER`, `JARL_TOKEN`, `JARL_VIEW` (optional) and `JARL_BIN`
(path to jarl, optional) in acme.sh's account configuration for renewals.
When they are unset, jarl's own configuration file is used.

## 5. A dedicated ACME zone (CNAME delegation)

Instead of letting a token write into your main zone, point each challenge
name at a small zone that exists only for ACME. The token may then write
only there:

```sh
jarl zone create acme.adbraun.lol --ns ns1.adbraun.lol.
jarl record add adbraun.lol acme NS ns1.adbraun.lol.          # delegate it
jarl record add adbraun.lol _acme-challenge     CNAME apex.acme.adbraun.lol.
jarl record add adbraun.lol _acme-challenge.www CNAME www.acme.adbraun.lol.

jarl user create acme --no-password --grant "records:write zones=acme.adbraun.lol types=TXT"
jarl token create acme --user acme -q > acme.token
```

The CA follows the CNAME, so the TXT record has to be written at its
target:

* **certbot**: add `--follow-cname` to both hooks, e.g.
  `jarl --token @/etc/jarl/acme.token acme certbot-auth --follow-cname`.
  jarl looks up `_acme-challenge.<domain>` and writes the TXT record at the
  target (`www.acme.adbraun.lol`). The lookup uses the host's resolvers.
  Add `--resolver 127.0.0.1` to ask the Jarl server directly, for example
  when the host's resolver sees a different view.
* **acme.sh** does the lookup itself:
  * `--challenge-alias acme.adbraun.lol` puts every TXT record at
    `_acme-challenge.acme.adbraun.lol`. Point all the CNAMEs there
    (`_acme-challenge.www CNAME _acme-challenge.acme.adbraun.lol.`).
  * `--domain-alias www.acme.adbraun.lol` writes at exactly that name.

  The hook passes acme.sh's full record name to `jarl acme --exact`, so both
  modes work.

A leaked ACME token can then only touch TXT records in the ACME zone, and
the main zone is never modified by automation.

## Troubleshooting

* `no primary zone that you can see contains ...`: the token's grants
  don't cover the zone, or the zone isn't a primary zone in Jarl.
* `permission denied: this needs records:write ...` (exit code 3): the
  record name or type isn't allowed for the token. Compare with
  `jarl --token @FILE whoami`.
* The CA says the TXT record is missing: check from outside with
  `dig @ns1.adbraun.lol _acme-challenge.adbraun.lol TXT`. With views, make
  sure the record is in the view that matches the CA (it is by default)
  and that `allow-query` lets the internet query the zone.
* `jarl audit --user certbot` shows every attempt.